Skip to main content
Is John Murtough’s Move to Atalanta the Dawn of a New Scam?

Is John Murtough’s Move to Atalanta the Dawn of a New Scam?

In a surprising turn of events that has sent shockwaves through the football community, former Manchester United football director John Murtough has taken up a new role as the Director of Global Development at Atalanta. This news comes just a year after his tumultuous departure from Old Trafford following a decade-long tenure filled with both triumphs and criticisms.

Murtough’s appointment is intriguing, especially considering the significant outlay Manchester United made for striker Rasmus Hojlund during his reign. The Danish forward was signed for a reported £72 million—an exorbitant fee that has left many United fans shaking their heads in incredulity.

Ex-Manchester United football director John Murtough joins Atalanta
Former Manchester United football director John Murtough joins Atalanta.

Fans took to social media in droves, branding Murtough’s previous dealings at United as a “scam.” One supporter tweeted, "This was part of the Hojlund scam," echoing sentiments that Murtough's inflated transfer strategy had been a significant contributing factor to his exit.

While Murtough’s role at Manchester United saw him rise through the ranks—culminating in his promotion to Football Director—it was not without its issues. Under his stewardship, United made several questionable transfer decisions that many now critique. Particularly, the sizeable fee for Hojlund has drawn ire, given that data suggested he was worth no more than £50 million at the time of the transfer.

Atalanta's announcement of Murtough’s hiring suggests a wider ambition for the burgeoning Serie A club, which recently clinched the Europa League title, marking a significant milestone in their history. The club aims to strengthen their global presence, and Murtough is expected to play a pivotal role in this strategy, working in coordination with sporting director Tony D'Amico.

Photo by Manchester United/Manchester United via Getty Images
Murtough's departure from Manchester United coincides with renewed ambition from Atalanta.

Critics, however, remain cynical about how Atalanta will thrive with Murtough’s track record. With one fan sarcastically questioning, "How do they trust him after successfully fleecing him?" this sentiment underscores a prevailing belief that Murtough's dealings at United were more a series of blunders than strategic successes.

The Serie A club is currently holding firm in third place in the league, just behind Napoli and Inter, and with growing aspirations to solidify their standing further. Murtough’s expertise, chiefly in scouting and development, could provide Atalanta with much-needed insights into player acquisition both locally and internationally.

As the football world watches Murtough's next chapter unfold, many wonder whether his experience will translate into success in Italy or if concerns over his previous costly dealings will haunt him even in a new setting.

What are your thoughts on Murtough's appointment at Atalanta? Is it a step towards strategic growth or merely a misstep in a game of high stakes football? Leave your comments below!

Can you Like

Manchester United striker Rasmus Hojlund is currently facing an uncertain future at Old Trafford as pressure mounts amidst a disappointing season for the football club. This situation raises important...
Manchester United fans and pundits alike are asking difficult questions about young Danish striker Rasmus Hojlund, whose dramatic slump in form continues to dominate headlines after a dismal Europa Le...
The summer transfer window is fast approaching, and it promises to be pivotal for Manchester United. Among the biggest stories swirling at Old Trafford is the potential departure of their expensive st...