Skip to main content
Why Did Haaland Give Up the Penalty? Wayne Rooney’s Bold Claim

Why Did Haaland Give Up the Penalty? Wayne Rooney’s Bold Claim

In a surprising twist at Wembley, Manchester City’s Erling Haaland has left fans and pundits puzzled after opting to pass on taking a crucial penalty during the FA Cup final against Crystal Palace. The decision ultimately led to a 1-0 defeat, and its implications may resonate throughout Haaland's burgeoning career.

City faced a disappointing loss to Crystal Palace, with the match highlighted by a missed penalty opportunity that could have levelled the score. Eberechi Eze’s goal had put Palace ahead early on, but City was awarded a penalty after Bernardo Silva was fouled in the box. Surprisingly, Haaland, usually the first-choice penalty taker, handed the ball to Omar Marmoush, who was unable to convert, having his shot saved by Dean Henderson.

Dean Henderson saves Omar Marmoush's penalty
Dean Henderson saves Omar Marmoush's penalty

Former Manchester United striker Wayne Rooney did not hold back in his analysis of the incident. Speaking on BBC Sport, he remarked, "There is no way Messi or Ronaldo would have let that happen. That’s the difference between them and players like Haaland or Mbappe—they are eager to score in every game. Their mentality drives them to seize such pivotal moments, as opposed to relinquishing them."

Despite Haaland’s impressive statistics, with 30 goals across all competitions this season, Rooney suggested that the weight of the occasion may have overwhelmed the Norwegian international. “The thought of taking a penalty at Wembley might have been too much for him. He is only human,” said Rooney.

City manager Pep Guardiola remarked that the penalty decision was made by the players on the pitch. “I thought he [Haaland] would want to take it, but they felt Omar was ready,” Guardiola stated post-match. This shows a remarkable amount of trust among teammates, yet it raises questions about Haaland's confidence and his current form, particularly after a recent injury layoff.

Dean Henderson handles the ball outside of his box to deny Erling Haaland
Dean Henderson handles the ball outside of his box to deny Erling Haaland

In the post-match discussions, Dean Henderson expressed his confidence in facing the penalty from Marmoush rather than Haaland, stating, “I knew which way he was going. I knew I would save it.” This sentiment raises further questions about trust within City’s squad and whether Haaland's penalty-taking abilities were perceived as compromised.

The incident not only points to a turning point in Haaland's season but also a potential awakening of his mentality in high-stakes situations. Former players like Alan Shearer expressed disbelief that Haaland would shy away from such a pivotal moment: “Whether he has missed three in a season or not, if you're fit and on the pitch, you should be ready to take the penalty.”

As Manchester City regroup after this latest disappointment, the aura surrounding Haaland's penalty decision will linger. For a player with aspirations to reach the heights of Messi and Ronaldo, the ability to shine in pressure situations becomes critical. Can he learn from this setback, or will it define his time at City? Only time will reveal the answers.

As fans reflect on Haaland's shocking decision, they must ask themselves: What does this mean for the young striker's future? Will he rise to the occasion in subsequent matches, or will doubts continue to cloud his promising career?

X talks about this news

Can you Like

In a stunning turn of events during the FA Cup final, Erling Haaland, the prolific striker for Manchester City, made headlines not for scoring, but for declining the opportunity to take a crucial pena...
In a match that will be etched in history, Crystal Palace claimed their first FA Cup title by defeating Manchester City with a remarkable 1-0 victory at Wembley Stadium. This unprecedented triumph not...
As Manchester United navigates one of the most turmoil-ridden seasons in recent memory, the call for a significant overhaul looms large. The club finds itself languishing in 16th place in the Premier ...