Ruben Amorim’s Kobbie Mainoo Dilemma: Reinvention, Growth And The Making Of A Manchester United Star

As Manchester United endure one of their most turbulent Premier League campaigns of the modern era, much of the conversation has pivoted from results to rebuilding — with new manager Ruben Amorim placing particular focus on nurturing the club’s young prodigy, Kobbie Mainoo. The 19-year-old’s development path has become a pressing issue, crucial not only for Mainoo’s personal progression but also for United’s future identity and tactical evolution.

Arriving at Old Trafford in 2024, Amorim inherited a talented yet underachieving United squad. His immediate impact in domestic competition has been mixed — with the team languishing outside the top ten as the season nears its conclusion — but a promising Europa League run hints at the club’s underlying potential. Central to unlocking that potential is the reinvention of Mainoo, whose unique midfield qualities present both an opportunity and a challenge for Amorim’s tactical vision.

Originally breaking through under Erik ten Hag, Mainoo showcased remarkable composure and technical skill despite his youth, becoming a symbol of hope for fans yearning for a new era. But injuries and an inconsistent team environment have stalled his momentum during the current campaign. Amorim’s experimental deployment of Mainoo — notably as a false nine in February’s defeat against Crystal Palace — resulted in a fleeting spark that quickly fizzled, underlining the need to refine rather than radically repurpose his role.

Increasingly, consensus is building that Mainoo’s future lies neither as a deep-lying orchestrator nor as an experimental striker, but as a dynamic No 10 who can exploit advanced midfield spaces. United legend Paul Scholes bluntly assessed this during a February appearance on The Overlap: “I think Mainoo is lost... he doesn’t know where to play on a football pitch because he’s been played in so many roles. The No 10 does suit, [but] the false nine, never in a million years.”

From Amorim’s perspective, Mainoo’s potential is tempered by clear developmental needs. The Portuguese coach has repeatedly pointed out three core areas for improvement: his pace within match rhythm, his contribution to United’s build-up phases, and overall physicality. Speaking ahead of United's Europa League clash with Lyon, he explained, “Near the box, he has a lot of talent… but I don’t see a full player at the moment; he is 19. If I say I have seen the final player, I don’t think I am helping Kobbie.”

Despite the critiques, United’s faith in their academy jewel remains steadfast. The club extended Mainoo’s contract to 2027, with ongoing discussions to better reflect his prominence in the squad. Rumours swirl about transfers, but insiders insist the focus is on centring Mainoo in the club’s medium-term plans, provided Amorim can mould his raw skillset to fit the demanding dynamics of the manager’s preferred 3-4-3 system.

One key hurdle is how Mainoo adapts to the athletic demands imposed on midfielders in Amorim’s setup. United’s engine room is asked to press assertively, transition swiftly, and support both defensive and attacking phases — attributes where Mainoo’s youth still shows. “I see some things Kobbie has to improve,” says Amorim, “but we have to be careful, especially with his recent injuries.” This cautious optimism illustrates both the promise and patience required in his long-term development.

For Manchester United, the Mainoo conundrum epitomises broader questions: can they build a tactical identity that elevates emerging talents? Will Amorim’s philosophical gamble pay off, reshaping a club starved of success into a team fusing youth with coherence? And most crucially, can Mainoo himself become more than just a symbol — can he mature into the midfield fulcrum capable of carrying United back to glory?

The answers will unfold gradually, but for now, Amorim’s willingness to critique, adapt, and reinvent marks a refreshing commitment amid stormy skies. Fans will watch closely, hopeful that this blend of tough love and tactical tinkering will unlock the best of Kobbie Mainoo — and perhaps signal the rebirth Manchester United so desperately crave.

What do you think about Amorim’s plans for Mainoo? Can the youngster thrive as an advanced midfielder or does he need a different approach? Share your thoughts below and join the conversation.

• Kobbie Mainoo
• Manchester United
• Ruben Amorim

X talks about this news